Personnel management vs human resource management

People in an organization carry out the entire task, from setting strategies and goals to allocating financial resources and from producing goods and services to marketing them. Therefore, the humans are considered to be 'human resource' or 'human capital' in an organization (Bratton and Gold, 2001). And managing this resource is crucial and the theory and practice of managing attended through several changes. The ever rising strong competition in the global business and spreading responsibilities brought dramatic changes in the manner approaches were made towards people management. The time business crossed the national boundaries and spread throughout different continents and various time zones it faced new challenges and difficulties in meeting the demands from the people of different cultures. Idea sharing and participation in decision making, therefore, became important as these can provide the organizations competitive edge in the changed environment. As a result the traits like aptitudes; commitment, ability to learn and tacit knowledge have grown to be obligatory to be able to possess continuous development (Bratton and Gold, 2001). Thus, the demands of the specialists as well as the formation of new ways of fit to the changed environment increased combined with the growth of business boundary.

Human Resource Management:

'Human resource management is a unique approach to employment management which seeksto obtain competitive advantage through the strategic deployment ofa highly committed and skilled workforce, using a range of cultural, structural and personnel techniques. ' (Storey, 1995).

Thus, HRM is mainly a set of policies that are manufactured aiming to obtain the organizational goal through the successful implementation of corporate strategy taking into consideration the human resource of the business as the driving force that can make the difference or quite simply give the company its most needed competitive advantage. Company needs to balance the aspirations of its people as well as its strategic demands towards making HRM policies.

There have been many models to clarify the idea Human Resource Management. Among the important models is Harvard model. The Harvard Framework preferred to start to see the whole process of HRM from the General Managers point of view (Armstrong, 2003). How they want to see the consequences of every step recognizing the importance of trade-offs between owners, employees and different interest groups (Armstrong, 2003). Here, the HR gets some outcomes as the direct affect of its policy choices and those outcomes brings the results that meet the stakeholder's interests. It suggests that the overall managers should develop a viewpoint, as they provide the strategic vision, of how they wish to see the employee involvement in achieving the goals.

Another important model is Warwick model. As Harvard model is developed in the American context it reflects the American style and way of managing HR but Warwick model reflects the European style (Loosemore et al. , 2003). Unlike Harvard model it focuses on external and internal both context and explores how both the internal and external environment influence the HR decisions (Bratton and Gold, 1999).

From Personnel to HRM:

The concept of HRM started getting shape in the early stage of commercial revolution (Bratton and Gold, 2001). Emerging concern of employee rights and the growth of trade union, changing reactions of the workforce and employers towards the general public policy, implementation of strict health insurance and safety regulations, increased demands of specialised personnel in the task force combined with the technological innovations, scientific and superior approach to managing employees and the ever ending competition in the market played vital role in the emergence of the concept Human Resource Management (Bratton and Gold, 2001). Though the concept is old however the title HRM was presented with to it only handful of decades back. Before that it was known as Personnel Management. Some scholars say that there surely is no actual difference between Personnel Management and HRM except the two different names (Storey, 2007; Armstrong, 2003; Torrington et al. , 2008).

Along with the emergence of the new economical order in 80s and 90s of last century the approach towards people management changed and the preference of treating personnel moved to individual rather then collective to be able to ensure that the very skilled and loyal employees gives the organization a competitive advantage (Bratton and Gold, 2001). Thus, changing the title is also a procedure for give the people management a fresh image to match to the changing environment. Torrington and Hall (1991, cited in Armstrong, 2003) sees the distinction as, Personnel Management is 'workforce centred' and for that reason directs itself to employees, on the other hand HRM is 'resource centred' concerns itself with the entire human resource needs of the organization.

Storey (2007) shows the detailed differences between Personal Management and HRM in his 27 points of variations where he categorized the elements into four-part basic outlines. They are; Beliefs and assumptions, Strategic Aspects, Line Management and Key levers (Storey, 2007). Miller (1998) integrated Storey's twenty seven points into six main points that focuses on the major points of distinction between Personnel Management and Human Resource Management.




Nature of relations



Speed of decision



Key managers




Job evaluation

Performance related

Job categories






Table: Personnel Management vs Human Resource Management (Miller, 1998)

So, the distinction between personnel and HR is clear. The largest change probably is focus. The focus has shifted from overall performance to individuals. Employee involvement through personal development is currently not only highly encouraged but also to ensure it the companies are undertaking different training and development programmes. An early example of this change was set by Ford when it announced its change initiatives that contain statement like 'employee involvement is our way of life' (Storey, 2007).

The Characteristics of HRM:

The attempt of HRM is to manage people, the most effective asset of any company, to achieve its goals and objectives. Thus, the typical characteristics of HRM include both the welfare of the business and the welfare of its employee. Armstrong (2003) pointed out some characteristics of HRM, these are;

  • It integrates the HR and business strategies and emphasizes the necessity for those strategic fit.
  • It is commitment oriented as it emphasizes on gaining the committed goals and mission of the organisation.
  • It attaches diversified cultures and values together and brings harmony at work.
  • It identifies the potentials of the employee and appoints the duty accordingly to guarantee the maximum benefits.
  • It manages and harnesses the potentials of the personnel and brings the best out of them.
  • It ensures both happiness of the personnel and happiness of the stakeholders.

The Functions HRM:

The basic HR functions according to Armstrong (2003) and Torrington et al (1991) are:

Human Resource Planning

The management determines the types and the number of human resources it needs to accomplish a task or reach the goal. In cases like this the management must consider the financial support available to it.

Recruitment and selection;

Proper recruitment and selection procedure must be followed in order to meet the demand of required skills. In this case the required skills can be tested through written or oral test or a blend of both.

Reward systems;

Reward systems are structured and measured by the company to keep carefully the employee motivated. It may include direct, indirect or psychological reward.

Employment legislation;

Terms and conditions, policies and opportunities for both parties should be open and written to avoid confusion. The HR department has to clearly mention the company policies in the employment contract.

Management of diversity;

As the business enterprise is now global the firms need to ensure a host where employees from different cultural, religious and ethnic groups are treated equal. Again, Ford's early realisation prompted them apply policies such as 'our doors are available to women and men alike without discrimination and without regard to ethnic origin or personal beliefs (Storey, 2007).

Training and development;

To make the employees better and prepare them for higher-level of obligations the HRM department will need a continuous training and development process. Along with the routine process the companies also train their employees throughout a sudden demand such as an addition of new software or hardware.

Grievance and discipline;

To ensure time keeping, good employee relations, proper behaviour and professional attitudes the HR department formulate company procedures.

Termination of employment relation;

As part of disciplinary action, end of the contract, the part of an employment cut or the relocation of the employee the HRM takes all the required actions.

Strategic HRM:

Human resource management is no more limited to managing people, recruiting, selecting, training and all the conventional administrative duties. As people will be the core competitive advantage in the current business, they are evaluated as the brainpower of the business rather than manpower. Just how of business competition is becoming knowledge based (storey et al, 2009). Thus, the human resource department plays a more strategic role today. Aside from all the administrative works Strategic HR participates on planning corporate strategy. It plans out the required skills and required effort necessary for a specific task to be carried out in future. SHRM also indicates a planned HR policy that integrates the business goal and could encompasses a number of HR ways of enhance the individual, thus business, performance to help make the reward system more effective (CIPD, 2010).

Miller (1998) says when a company have the ability to establish an appropriate fit between strategy and HRM it could be regarded as practising strategic HRM.

The business strategy and the strategic human resource management run in parallel, both are informative and communicative. Information open to SHRM about how precisely people are motivated deployed and the availability of skills and knowledge might determine the business strategy, on the other hand when business strategy requires the improvement of customer support this will most likely shape the training plans and performance improvement plans (CIPD, 2010).

Approaches to SHRM:

Strategic HRM is mainly a resource based philosophy which encompasses three possible approaches (Armstrong, 2003). They are explained bellow:

Resource based SHRM: Resource based HRM strategy focuses on the performance of the employee and compare the productivity of its people with the competitors. In this process learning is highly encouraged and the intellectual capital is developed and nurtured.

High-performance management approach: By developing the abilities of the employees and improving the self management capacity and team performance the HR department can actually improve the overall productivity and ensure client satisfaction. Here, the quality leadership, vision, benchmarking and decentralization are suggested in order to acquire greater success (Stevens, 1998; cited in Armstrong, 2003).

High performance approach additionally require to have a rigorous recruitment and selection procedure, an effective learning and development process and merit pay and profit sharing to encourage powerful (Armstrong, 2003).

High involvement management: This approach says employees should be treated as partners, their interests should be respected and their equal involvement in decision making should be encouraged. A good communication between the managers and the employees that gives clear knowledge of organizational vision, values and the expectation of both parties can achieve the business its expected productivity.

Characteristics of SHRM:

There are some characteristics of SHRM can be drawn from the writing of Salaman et al (2005) and Armstrong (2003). These are discussed below:

-It connects the whole process to the business enterprise strategy and plays a proactive role rather than reactive. Rather than waiting for the instruction and complaints strategic HR managers take proactive steps and plans out the future outcome.

-SHRM is output driven. It requires all strategic steps to improve the performance of the employees and achieve the overall competitive advantage.

-It is more preventive than corrective and thus it value employees who are multi-skilled, cross-functional and team players. It expects visitors to do the things write the first attempt.

-It supplies the guidance to other parts of the organization on what to measure, how to measure and how to report the outcomes of the measurement CIPD (2010)

Dave Ulrich (1997) suggested four strategic roles in order to be able to create real value to the business. They are:

  1. Strategic partner: Here, the HR manger help the company turn the strategy into result. He will measure the existing strategy and find out whether you can find any strategic change needed.
  2. Change agent: HRM helps the change happen and it happens faster. Also make sure human resource understand and cope up with the change.
  3. Employee champion: managing and evaluating talents or the intellectual capital and
  4. Administrative expert: Ensuring the all the human resource related jobs are done and they're done in a manner that helps the business enterprise.

Effect of Globalization:

Globalization is shortening the trade barriers, making the market more open and so more competitive. It is a very influencing source that fuelling the changes faster. Toyota, one of the greatest car producers in the world, was the hundredth Japanese company when it made a decision to locate their first UK based manufacturing facility in Derby (Storey, 2007). But it took fifteen years, from 1972-87, for the first fifty Japanese companies to reach in UK and the next fifty companies found its way to following 2 yrs time (Storey, 1992, p. 12). The challenges that globalization has taken to Human Resource Management and the they must be faced are:

Restructuring: Business is expanding in one way or other. Either two or more businesses of same industry are merging together or an example may be acquiring the other. As a direct result of this the business eliminate layers of managers, closes facilities and cut jobs. HR managers are facing challenges in managing people who worked in different company cultures and some whom withdraw their loyalty. Even sometimes when the companies from different countries of different time zones merge than language and cultures become the key concern (CIPD, 2011).

-In this regard the HR professionals need work in co-operation with other organizational sections. Need to understand different organizational management policy and take the professional through smooth transition process.

Management of diversity: As an impact of globalisation people from different cultures, ethnic groups and religion come in a single place and interact and they need a mutual understanding that make the way to productivity smooth.

-Here, the HR department must ensure a working environment that offers equal opportunity and respect to the people from all background (CIPD, 2010). They have to understand different cultural and religious values.

Technological innovation: Continuous innovation of new technology put pressure on HR department of the company to ensure a continuous training and development programme. Also, the technologies are reducing HR tasks that create the chance of HR job cuts.

-HR professionals need to make themselves equipped with latest technological knowledge. They have to diversify themselves and be useful in participating other organizational tasks.

Outsourcing: Outsourcing concept has come up combined with the globalization. Organizations are now outsourcing some of their task to others that may be located various other area of the world. Thus, some of the HR functions now to be done by the line managers (Kumar, 2011).

-Along with other qualifications the line managers need to have the proper knowledge of Human Resource Management. On the other hand the HR managers need to outline and monitor the HR task of the line managers.

Economic and political change: Economic changes such as global recession, change in government policy consequently of the shift in political power force the companies to close facilities and decrease production cost. As a direct result of this organizations decrease the size of HR body and put pressure on the remaining to become more productive (Kumar, 2011).

-Through the effective training and development process the HR managers must ensure top level productivity of the human capital that will reduce production cost and make the organization more sustainable.


Human Resource Management has come through different changes and challenges on the modern times. Though, the innovation of technologies is reducing a few of the HR tasks but these affecting the HR roles very less. Also, outsourcing is also happening in a number of cases thus it is not affecting HR roles significantly (CIPD, 2006). Yet outsourcing may decrease the HR task of a business but it is shifting those tasks to another companies. The expense of owning a HR department may fall and rise but at the end it repay with the improved productivity it brings to the human resource of the company. The human resource still remains the competitive advantage factor and it'll remain so in the future. Different market boundaries are falling apart and forming one single global market. With this marketplace different companies of a business are experimenting all possible and available resources to achieve the competitive advantage. But it is human resource that can offer additional features to a company through a continuous development process. Thus, the duty of men and women management is not limiting rather its expanding. A dynamic human resource management body can attract the best bunches of talent by designing and offering exceptional reward and career opportunity package and at the same time it can increase the productivity of its existing resource to the highest level by planning, developing and implementing an efficient training and development programme. For instance, Microsoft and Google both have se's. The amount of users by using a internet search engine determines its business success. Now, people use the internet search engine that consists of highest amount of resources and offering additional features that carry the better value then the others. The human resources are bringing all the features and widening work at home opportunities in these both cases. Which is the HRM department that recruits those professionals through a highly effective selection and recruitment process, offering them their dream package of reward and compensation, and down the road it brings those professionals to this level through a proper training and development. Thus, the Human Resource Management is vital for organizational survival in today's marketplace.

  • More than 7,000 students prefer us to work on their projects
  • 90% of customers trust us with more than 5 assignments
submit a project

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
Shiseido Company Limited Is A Japanese Makeup Company Marketing Essay
Marketing Strength: Among the main talents of Shiseido is its high quality products. To be able to satisfy customers, the company invested a great deal...
Fail To Plan You Plan To Fail Management Essay
Management This report will concentrate on two aspects of project management, their importance within the overall project management process. The report...
Role of High-protein Diet in Weight Management
Nursing Structured Representation: Probably one of the most wide-spread and popular problems on earth is the weight problems that people is suffering...
Waste To Prosperity Program Environmental Sciences Essay
Environmental Sciences Urban and rural regions of India produce very much garbage daily and hurting by various kinds of pollutions which are increasing...
Environmental Studies Pollution Introduction Many people across the world can remember having walked on the street and seen smoke cigars in the air or...
Soft System Methodology
Information Technology Andrzej Werner Soft System Methodology can be described as a 7-step process aimed to help provide a solution to true to life...
Strategic and Coherent methods to Recruiting management
Business Traditionally HRM has been regarded as the tactical and coherent method of the management of the organizations most appreciated assets - the...
Religious Healthcare Organisation
Health Religious Health Care Introduction I help the firm of consulting. Spiritual HEALTHCARE of Middleville community have appointed us to identify and...
Enterprise Rent AN AUTOMOBILE Case Analysis Business Essay
Commerce With a massive network of over 6,000 local rental locations and 850,000 automobiles, Organization Rent-A-Car is the greatest rental car company...
Check the price
for your project
we accept
Money back
100% quality