A basement car park has to be design in this job to meet up with the property developers need. The car area will have 3 below walk out as the physique attached in the appendix (site 2). A site analysis has been completed and supplied as the information in this job. The construction technique for the basement surfaces needs to be recognized, then design the basement wall space and create a report justifying the solution.
1. 2 Job Goal and Objective
This project subject is established for student who's having their third year analysis in Civil and Structural Engineering. The aim of this task is to reveal the design and construction procedure for a geotechnical framework that students will probably come across in their future industry life.
There are several goal need to be achieved in order to meet the aim in this project. Those seeks are:
To gain the entire thinking in a job structure and understanding those factors affect the introduction of the project.
To gain deeper knowledge in the geotechnical field such as type of retaining structure and soil information.
To develop the logical thinking and view of the constructability of the task.
To identify the anatomist problems in a task and decrease it to the least.
To justify the proposed ideas into engineering areas.
To apply anatomist thinking into a task and design the structure relating.
To talk to the supervisor for seeking appropriate advice and home study to complete the task.
1. 3 Task Scope
This project have been separated into two main parts that happen to be conceptual design and detailing design.
In the conceptual design part, the options of pile have to be considered correctly and justify it before get into the detailing design part. In this particular job, there are several type of retaining composition can be used but just the most appropriate one will be chosen to carry out into the describing design part. A couple of few factors need to be concerned while selecting the decision of retaining framework. Those factors are the type of soil, longevity, constructability, predicted costs and more. By having a good comparability among kind of retaining structure, then your most adoptable type of retaining structure will be decided on to create the retaining wall membrane.
For the detailing design part, an adequate design calculation must be produced in order to show that the retaining composition is satisfied with several circumstances and sufficient drawings need to be well prepared if needed. The building sequences have to indentify and list out evidently. Finally, an in depth method assertion for the safe structure of the building including any helping risk assessments, and an overview construction programs by means of a bar need to be provided.
2. 0 Background Review and Constraints
The background research is the first stage of this entire task and a work must to be achieved before a project begin to advance on. The primary reason for this stage is to assemble information as much as possible and analysis to determine the restriction of the project.
There must be some limitation in every one project that must be concerned and further rational thinking to control a good design. The debate of the constraints needs to be done in the first part of the project then the better final design will be produced by passing through this process.
2. 1 Deep Excavation and Site
The site tolerance is limited credited to a general population highway located just next to the footpath which is 2m from the site. There must be some disruption will face by the general public highway because of this significant issue. This aspect must be considering while choosing the sort of retaining structure to be construct and lessening it to the minimum amount when the development is certainly going on.
Deep excavation needs to be taking part in this entire job, so the risks of deep excavation either recognized or unsupported circumstance needs to be indicated which is a considerable concern while making decision for the type of earth retaining composition. For example, the dewatering problems might be exist bottom part on the normal water stand and the excavation is variable foundation on different type of soil in the area as well.
2. 2 Ground Profiles
The soil profiles are the interesting and relating to part for the geotechnical engineering especially the anatomist soils found under the topsoil [1]. The anatomist properties and the behavior of these soils are their concerning and interesting point [1].
Different type of soil information will be having different capability for a structure. Therefore, site exploration process must carry out to look for the soil information. The part and the type of soil or rock beneath the surface surface will be dependant on this technique. Its behaviour and the properties of each part will be obtained as well to progress on.
In this project, there are three boreholes given from the site analysis data which known as as BH-02, BH-03 and BH-09. The boreholes record is attached behind the statement which in the appendix part (from web page 1 to webpage 2). The location of BH-02 and BH-03 are shown inside the plan view of the site but there may be nothing highly relevant to BH-09 can be figured out from the view. The program view is attached in the appendix (web page 1). A simple analytic of the height and depth of every layer have done which shown in the Number 2. 1, 2. 2 and 2. 3.
C:\Users\Fuh\Desktop\Zzz_Analysis things\CIVE 3709\Task\IMG_0619. JPG
Figure 2. 1 Borehole Record, BH-02
C:\Users\Fuh\Desktop\IMG_0617. JPG
Figure 2. 2 Borehole Record, BH-03
C:\Users\Fuh\Desktop\IMG_0618. JPG
Figure 2. 3 Borehole Record, BH-09
From the shape of the three boreholes files, it shown they are a comparable. The soil profiles for the top layer is manufactured ground then followed by clay and then mudstone as the bottom layer.
Clay is a in a natural way occurring material composed mainly of fine-grained nutrients, which is generally cheap at appropriate water contents and will harden with dried out or terminated. Although clay usually includes phyllosilicates, it could contain other materials that impart plasticity and harden when dried out or fired. Associated phases in clay can include materials that do not impart plasticity and organic matter [14]. Within the other hands, mudstone is an excellent grained sedimentary rock which is shaped by clays or muds with the pressure over very long time. It looks like solidified clay but with respect to the situation when it was produced.
2. 3 Water level
Groundwater observation where in fact the water seeps or ingress should be recorded in the site inspection logs as they link with the casing and the boreholes depth [2]. Groundwater observation is the matter for geotechnical anatomist due to the normal water pressure too. Water pressure can be an concern that will affect the decision of the choice of retaining framework and the depth of the pile as well.
The water desk is not given in this particular project specs therefore proper factor is needed prior to making any assumption. This inflatable water level is to be assumed one meter below ground level after an extended thought and communication with supervisor. This should be the best assumption and go on for the later part of design.
2. 4 Time, Cost and Quality
As a custom, the matter of the property developer needs to be considering while planning a job. Time, cost and quality are participating in the important assignments for an individual project which is the matter of the developer. These three elements will be the key issues and related to each other. The cost of the project will be increased if a project development time getting longer. Base on this, the shorter the engineering period the lower the cost of the job so an effective planning of the building method and technique is needed to minimize the development cost but the quality of the task must be still maintain in a fulfill adoptable level.
3. 0 Kind of Earth Retaining Structure
Earth retaining buildings are mainly utilized to support the garden soil and structure due to the difference in elevation of the bottom surface. It could be either propped or cantilever. There is various kind of earth retaining constructions which are being used in geotechnical field for civil engineering. Those retaining framework more commonly found in basement carpark and more ideal for this job are:
Sheet Pile Walls
Diaphragm Walls
Bored Pile Walls
There differs capable of each kind of wall, the typical applications of wall surfaces show in the number below.
Figure 3. 1 Typical applications of embedded walls ([8] webpages 98)
3. 1 Sheet Pile Walls
Sheet pile surfaces are made of timber or precast concrete recently but nowadays sheet pile surfaces are additionally made of material. Sheet pile wall surfaces are made by individually motivated sheet pile in to the floor and form the group of interlocking piles to support the land and the structure [1]. Sheet pile wall can be category into two main types which are cantilever wall membrane and anchored wall structure.
Sheet hemorrhoids are light to take care of and being powerful. It can handle the high compressive tons whiles it motivated into a hard ground surface [3]. It has the ability of being driven into profound penetration to attain a bearing stratum or even to create a high frictional amount of resistance [3].
There are two method of driving sheet hemorrhoids into stratum which is:
Pitch and Drive
This is the easiest method, each sheet pile or couple of piles will be driving into the completed level (full depth) before duplicating another sheet pile. By the way, this method is more suitable for loose soils and brief piles only.
Panel Driving
In this technique, the first couple of piles needs to be pitched carefully, plumbed and powered partly to form adjacent piles. Then, the rest of the of piles are pitched and interlocked. Finally, the previous pair of hemorrhoids pitched in to the -panel are then driven partially and accompanied by the partial driving a car of all of those other panel, working again on the first set in the panel [4].
The hemorrhoids is established as whole -panel, therefore it is no need to drive all piles fully to keep the piling functions. The chance of generating problem and difficulties of de-clutching will be minimised too [5]. This method is ideal for dense sands and stiff cohesive soils.
http://www. earthwork. us/files/DSCN2063. JPG
Figure 3. 2, Sheet Pile Walls
There are few issues need to be discuss while considering to be used sheet pile walls for design. Firstly, the profound of the basement has to be constructed. If the depth of the basement too profound which mean the space of the pile will be quite long and the power of moving, pitching and motivated those piles needs to be taken into account especially in metropolitan area. Cost will be affected in this matter as well because it is hard to manufacture a big size of sheet piles.
Basement carpark recently produced in metropolitan area to fully utilize the space in the towns. While sheet pile wall space can be act as a permanent framework or non permanent work in a development project, but there's a matter if the sheet hemorrhoids act as the momentary work. The ability to remove the sheet piles after built the retaining structure should be think twice base on the limited areas around the places for the crane to remove it.
Even you can find some improvement of the technology on the sound and vibration problems for sheet piles while powered it in to the stratum but vibration and noise are still leave which is the negatives of sheet piles. The improvement just mainly overcomes the situation on some form of soil coating only, such as by using some hydraulic pressure equipment to press the sheet hemorrhoids into stiff clay covering. Make reference to this entire issue; there has to be rational factor if steel pile should be used specially in the urban area.
3. 2 Diaphragm Walls
A diaphragm wall structure fundamentally is the combination of strengthened concrete wall membrane and sheet pile wall membrane. It gets the capacity of the blend of strengthened concrete and sheet pile wall structure. A diaphragm wall structure are shaped and set by vertical strengthened concrete slab constantly in place with the same manner to support the soil. Inside the other hands, the sheet pile kept in the lower part of the diaphragm wall membrane by the passive and productive soil stresses that act after it [1].
Most of the diaphragm wall surfaces are the strengthened concrete wall membrane that ensemble in situ by way of a machine digging a trench in sections of limited size. It functions as short-term support during engineering and a long term wall, sometimes with lining [8]. The stableness of the excavation to the mandatory depth is filled by the use of a drilling smooth, usually is bentonite slurry [6]. This slurry has thixotropic properties, as it forms into gel when still left undisturbed but becomes a liquid when disturbed [1]. The bentonite slurry initially penetrates into the dirt and the nearly impervious pores and skin of bentonite allergens is produced [1]. It is merely about few millimetres thick on the edges of the trench. There is no penetration of the slurry into clays, sand and silt water. The main aim of the utilization of slurry is to prevent collapse of the trench by creates lateral pressures that act privately of the brief trench -panel.
When the excavation is performed, the required steel support is place into the trench -panel. The wall space are designed by filled with cement in discrete panel lengths ranging typically between 2. 5m and 7. 0m using purpose in appropriate circumstances. Those displaced slurry being gathered for cleaning and additional use. Standard widths of diaphragm walling equipment are 600, 800, 1000, 1200 and 1500mm although increased can be provided as required. Depths of the diaphragm wall are produced up to 50m by using grabs or more to 80m using standard hydromills (milling machines). The remaining intermediate panels are excavated and constructed to totally complete the wall membrane when the cement is rolling out sufficient strength. The distance of each -panel is bound to the amount that the ground will arch, in a horizontal route, to support the floor until the concrete has been put [6].
A simplified Physique 3. 3 has been mounted on shown the many construction stages. In the Figure 3. 3, the operations of each stage are:
Guide-wall construction
Panel excavation in progress
Installing stop ends
Panel concreting
Figure 3. 3, the stage of development a diaphragm wall space.
http://www. stroyinject. com/images/gallery/pics_new. 08. 08/thumb_SZ_2. JPG
Figure 3. 4, Diaphragm Walls
There still is out there another type of diaphragm walls that are precast strengthened concrete diaphragm walls. The use with this kind of diaphragm wall membrane is nearly the same with diaphragm wall that reinforced concrete cast in situ. It provides both short-term and permanent earth support but with limited depth.
There must be some advantages and disadvantages for every single earth retaining structure. Therefore the talk of pros and cons for this type of retaining structure must be done, while considering of using diaphragm surfaces.
The development time and cost of diaphragm wall is generally reliable where it is utilized for both long lasting and temporary subsoil retention for walls of medium, and increased, depth [8]. Diaphragm surfaces also permit the effective transfer of vertical insert from the building superstructure to subsoil below basement level. The vertical fill transfer is not added in the wall design as the early on of diaphragm wall structure in UK. The reluctance of designers to allow such load transfer was due without doubt to lack of published test results. This situation altered little by little when the diaphragm more commonly use within the structure of basement [8].
While constructing the diaphragm walls, it gets the minimum sound and vibration disturbance. This is an good thing about using diaphragm walls as a keeping structure. The noises and vibration in diaphragm wall membrane installation are a comparable compare with the normal civil anatomist equipment, such as cranes and generators. Base upon this, it appropriate to be constructed in urban area. Diaphragm surfaces can be built under groundwater condition so there is not any affection in groundwater problems because of this kind of composition. Diaphragm walls have advantages of high bearing capacity and good in horizontal or vertical bearing capacity. The allowances of settlement because of this kind of composition are small which is wonderful for superstructure [9].
Although there are many advantages of using diaphragm wall membrane but there exists some limitations because of this structure to be used. It could not be use either in very smooth earth such as very soft clay due to trench balance problem or very stiff rock.
The principal cons of diaphragm walling are the risk of loss or spillage of bentonite slurry, the relatively high cost of cleaning and the removal of the slurry, the site space needed for large reinforcement cages and the large cranes needed to handle them. Above all, the need for continuity in the structure process from excavation through concreting to removal of temporary stop formers is a disadvantage of the technique [8].
A good quality control is necessary in the diaphragm wall construction. Diaphragm surfaces will be the new kind of retaining framework which is newer and develop by some modern equipment. Those skilful and more specialist personnel needed while assembly the wall surfaces.
3. 3 Bored Pile Walls
Bored pile wall surfaces are an earth retaining composition that form by bored ensemble in situ hemorrhoids either small or large diameter. This system often used in deep basements and underground structure as a temporary or everlasting retaining framework. It popular for those set ups with limited working space or constraint of adjacent existing set ups that prevent increased bulk excavation and help control the motion of the bottom [6].
The construction approach to bored pile walls are somewhat different compare to the diaphragm wall membrane, at first a casing must be driven into the ground utilizing the vibro-hammer and giving 1 metre length of the casing above the bottom. Casing can be ignored where the dirt profiles are strong to stiff cohesive soils [11]. The power-driven rotary auger (a drilling tool) will be used to cut and take away the garden soil within the casing to create a borehole. The number of diameters and depths possible is substantial, from 300 to over 5000mm and down to 100. The used of the casing is to support the surrounding dirt. If the space of the casing not enough long to reach the mandatory depth in the ground, bentonite slurry could be utilized to support the soil below the casing. The metal support will be lifted up and placed into the borehole by crane. If the depth of the boreholes too deep, reinforcements have to be over lapping and welding when possible. The cement is poured into the borehole to create the bored pile. Finally, the bored pile is developed by using the vibro-hammer to withdrawn the casing [3][10].
A bored pile wall has its characteristic which have to take into consideration while selecting the sort for retaining framework. The presence of the advantages and down sides of the bored pile walls need to be taken into account if bored pile walls chosen to be utilized.
The amount of bored pile wall space can be varied to match the varying ground condition which is more adoptable for most of the design task. Moreover, the earth can be inspected and if necessary sampled or in situ lab tests made when it's cut and taken off the boreholes. Employing this method, the large excavations and subsequent backfill are taken out. The noise and vibration are existed while making the bored to death pile but it is suitable and will not disturb the adjacent pile or composition [12].
Basically, the drawbacks of bored stiff pile wall aren't much. The travel of the casing could be one from it. The unable to place the concrete under the ideal condition and cannot subsequently inspected are one of the down sides as well.
Figure 3. 5, the steps of building contiguous bored stiff pile wall space.
Bored pile wall space are categorised into two types, which are:
Contiguous Bored Pile Walls
Secant Bored Pile Walls
Several factors have to be concerned while choosing the type of bored pile wall space. Those factors are:
Soil Type
The ground normal water profile
Construction time available
Propping requirements
Cost
Life span
3. 3. 1 Contiguous Bored Pile Walls
A sole row or two times row of piles pitched and made next to one another with leaving some gaps. Alternative piles are cast first and the intermediate piles are then installed. Amount 3. 6 and Figure 3. 7 are attached for greater detail and understanding. Because of this type of keeping structure, water will stream through the spaces between hemorrhoids [1]. This type retaining structure ideal where in fact the soils are between firm to stiff and this level is below the depth of excavation. This method is the speediest method & most economic option to construct.
Figure 3. 6, a good example for the program view of contiguous bored to death pile wall
http://www. sbe. napier. ac. uk/esm/images/bored_pile_small. jpg
Figure 3. 7, contiguous weary pile wall
3. 3. 2 Secant Bored Pile Walls
Secant bored pile wall space are similar with the contiguous bored to death pile wall, except that the difference of the piles are either filled up with concrete or extra pile are cut into the key hemorrhoids as shown in Number 3. 8 and Shape 3. 9. This strategy is ideal for high water level due to the continuous wall acquired formed which is a watertight condition that prevents the inflow of drinking water. The procedure of this method is just a bit more complicated compare to tired pile wall structure.
Figure 3. 8, a good example of plan view of secant bored to death pile walls
http://www. amplusltd. com/upldimages/ISecant%20piled%20wal%20-%20Battricks%20-MG_0042. jpg
Figure 3. 9, Secant weary pile walls
4. 0 Comparing and Selecting Of Retaining Framework.
By using a simple matrix evaluation stand as shown in Stand 4. 1, it can be decided the best collection of retaining set ups as on the whole concept. The selection of the retaining structures can be determined by rational comparisons through the use of the weighting into the matrix desk. The weighting in the matrix table are displayed with numerical figures from 1 to 3 in which the higher the value, the more beneficial for the route while the lower the worthiness indicates as otherwise.
From the stand, it shown that all type of the retaining set ups is about the same, they have their own feature and advantages in several aspects. Secant weary pile wall space gained the most point in the weighting but it might not be the best choice because this is just a general principle comparing within the sort of retaining buildings so a proper comparison that match this entire project issues will be achieved down the road.
The soil information of this project are made floor, company to stiff clay and mudstone which adoptable for all of the retaining structure mentioned above except sheet pile wall space. In this soil conditions, sheet pile surfaces are not ideal to be motivated into the surface due to the hardness of the mudstone part. This issue can be fixed by giving bigger size of sheet pile which significantly increased the price and waste of materials. Therefore, sheet pile wall space are not suggested and when possible choose other type of retaining composition into design.
Water level is a challenge which will be affected the decision of selecting keeping structures. The level is to be assumed at 1m below walk out. It really is quite high and proper account must be done base upon this issue. Diaphragm surfaces, sheet pile wall space and secant pile wall surfaces are capable to create in high drinking water level condition. Contiguous pile wall space are not able to construct below floor water condition due to the gaps between the piling which allowed the inflow of this. This might a concern while selecting this as the keeping structures.
Diaphragm surfaces are a good retaining framework among all of the retaining structure. It allowed the best depth of excavation which is about 7 to 30m size but 8m of excavation is sufficiently enough in this complete project. In the other side, the other keeping structures are more adoptable which allowed 4 to 15 or 20m depth of excavation period. This can be a concern while selecting the choice of retaining structures.
Basically, there may be specific difficulty of making each type of retaining buildings just in different restriction. There is not much to touch upon the ease of construct issue but it must be fit with the site restriction. The durability of every type retaining composition is approximately the same and maybe it's ignored while checking with one another. The cost of engineering must be minimizing to the least if possible since it is a problem of the project developer and cost-effective problem.
Sheet pile walls are declined in this job due to several concerns. First, the main concern of using sheet pile is the scale and area of the pile to be used due to the depth and part of excavation are quite big. It is hard to manufacture such big size of sheet pile in the stock and hard to transport large number of them to the website. If sheet pile chosen into design for basement car park, it will commonly become momentary work and the ability to withdraw the sheet piles after the development is an concern because a highway just located 2m from the boundary of the website. Moreover, the ground profile contains whole lot of the mudstone which cause the sheet pile hard to be driven into the floor. You will see some vibration which will be affected the public highway either on the building blocks or the whole structure as the sheet pile is driven into the floor.
Diaphragm wall surfaces are good to be used in basement engineering which is commonly in urban area. Honestly, it is suitable with all the current construction constraints in this entire job such as with the ability to construct under groundwater condition and there isnt any vibration problem in diaphragm wall surfaces construction. Even it is so good equate to other retaining buildings but it still will never be selecting as the retaining structure. First, large amount of steel reinforcements needed for a diaphragm walls, it need to be tied up before they lifted up by crane and placed into the panels. Base on the number of materials and skilful staff needed, the cost of the building will increased immediately. It is also relatively high cost of cleaning and the removal of the slurry. Diaphragm wall space are good enough which is a bit over because of this project because some of the advantages is not needed in this project. Consequently, diaphragm wall surfaces are not ideal for this project plus some other retaining composition can do because the overall estimated structure cost is very costly equate to others.
Bored pile walls will be the most enough retaining composition to be used in this job compare to others. Even there are a few disadvantages in this type of retaining structure but the advantages of using it are higher after proper concern and looking at. Then, the vibration and noise of constructing uninterested pile walls are in the satisfactory range and will not have an impact on those composition next to it especially the general public highway. Bored pile walls are able to consort with the garden soil conditions in this job too. It's the cheapest retaining composition as well. Weary pile walls are chosen either secant weary pile wall or contiguous weary pile wall structure.
As a conclusion, secant bored to death pile wall membrane is chosen as the keeping composition in this task since it offers a watertight alternative compare with contiguous uninterested pile surfaces.
4. 1 Selected Retaining Structure " Secant Bored Pile Walls
Secant bored to death pile walls fundamentally are bored ensemble in situ piles either small or large diameter. It will be created in a series and the difference between piling will be filling with concrete or concrete to form a watertight condition for protecting against the inflow of water. The filling approach will be talked about in the later part of record.
Secant bored to death pile walls are categorised into 3 types that happen to be:
Hard / Soft Secant Pile Wall
Hard / Organization Secant Pile Wall
Hard / Hard Secant Pile Wall
4. 1. 1 Hard / Soft Secant Pile Wall
The woman pile has a quality compressive power of 10-20 N/mm2, which is retarded to lessen the strength of the mix as the mail piles are drilled between your female piels.
4. 1. 2 Hard / Company Secant Pile Wall
4. 1. 3 Hard / Hard Secant Pile Wall
