The Cultural Imperialism Thesis

In contemporary contemporary society, globalization has become an inevitable development of the development. In 1985, Theodre Levitt first proposes the idea of globalization; it is utilized to spell it out the changes and development in the global overall economy. Since then, the concept of globalization gradually blends into other medical areas and it speedily becomes a favorite subject in academia. Set alongside the disputes on economical and political level, the issues of culture are usually more subtle plus more profound. Tomlison (1997) points out that due to the imbalance of economical strength, appropriately, in cultural domain name it is split into dominant and vulnerable, that is the reason why ethnic imperialism has been suggested. Therefore, keeping the freedom of their own culture in the exchanges of globalization is just about the reason people questioned the ethnical globalization. As Lechner (2012, p. 340) confirms that 'Modern press are carriers of globalization', global civilizations are dispersing through the media, like the Internet and satellite television, it is the media which can turn the planet into a global town and make people feel nearer than ever before. With the growth of advertising and cultural globalization process, recent developments in this field have resulted in a renewed desire for whether the social imperialism thesis can be seen as a way to comprehend press globalization, and it's been a controversial and much disputed subject matter in present population.

This essay begins by tracing again some debates and the annals about mass media globalization and then it will go on to demonstrate an understanding of the cultural imperialism and the key components of it. After detailing some main critiques of the ethnical imperialism thesis, this paper seeks to verify that as an increasing amount of countries gradually realize that it is important to protect and develop their local culture, the ethnical imperialism thesis appears to be an unsuitable way to comprehend media globalization in the current international environment.

Media Globalization

Most scholars believe that globalization must be associated with advertising and communications, the definition of globalization indirectly acknowledged this point. Giddens (1990, p. 64 cited in Sreberny-Mohammadi, 2000, p. 118) defines globalization as "the intensification of worldwide social relations which web page link distant localities in such a way that local happenings are molded by events happening many mls away and vice versa". Just what links the faraway localities? The answer will be the media. Because of the progress of media technology, the contact and communication between people from different places becomes more convenient, as Jameson (1998, p. 55) points out that "globalization is a communicational concept, which alternately masks and transmits cultural or economical meanings". It is McLuhan (1964) who first recognise the role of press, although he proposes the term 'global community' which appears to be a negative way to understand globalization. His merit is to demonstrate the result of communication solutions in our public life. Referring to media globalization, it seems that the introduction of it can be grouped into different historical periods by three significant kinds of mediums. To get started with, ranges are no more obstacles to transnational communication due to emergence of the telegraph. Relating to Thompson (1995), it was cable connection networks which connect European countries with China, Australia and SOUTH USA, making mega mass followers get information across the world. In the second place, Tomlinson (2004) areas that the industrialized countries had been linked by satellite television on pc. It had cracked through enough time and space limitations so that worldwide people can sit in front of televisions and watch the same happenings or soap operas at the same time. More exactly, that's the reason why teleplays like Dallas can be extensively distributed. Finally, as modern tools is advancing at an instant velocity, as a advertising carrier the internet has completely changed just how people get information. It brings information from different countries and diverse areas of the entire world to the individual computers or laptops.

The performances of media globalization can be partitioned into three aspects. Firstly, as an important representation of the diverse national economy and culture, multimedia products are distributing across the globe. People just need to press some control keys on the handy remote control or computer keyboard and then they can access the mass media products they need from almost any country via satellite tv or online press, such as information, TV programs and cleaning soap operas. For many Chinese teenagers, they concern about American technology reports to learn about the latest electric products, their mp3 players are participating in the popular sounds of Woman Gaga and Adele; American Television series are their favourites, such as Vampire Diaries along with the Big Bang Theory. Press globalization means not only the dissemination of mass media products, but also the campaign of advertising commercialization which is now the universal advertising form. In other words besides the media productions themselves; the proliferation of Traditional western multimedia form includes the type and form of programs and professional details and convention. Take Chinese language TV program for example, media studio buys overseas make model and then change the program to match the viewing habits of Chinese people. China's Got Talent is the most successful circumstance which comes from Britain's Got Ability; it has documented audience ranking for three times.

The second facet of multimedia globalization is the dominating position of transnational marketing company and market. The merger and acquisition of multimedia companies have produced the large-scale marketing group; for illustration, the seven main global press giants which can be Disney, AOL - Time Warner, Sony, Information Company, Viacom, Vivendi and Bertelsmann (McChesney, 2000). Helped by the supranational strength and nation-state strength, these media groupings sweep across the globe through various systems and agencies. Since the nation is no longer the service provider of multimedia service, the constraints are released in press possession and broadcast communications domain name. Globalization embodied in conditions of ownership framework, production, syndication and ingestion of new transnational mass media systems. Through mergers and acquisitions, the mass media system that used to possess distinctive nationwide characteristics is now related to multinational marketing groups. Similarly, the production and intake of advertising, such as film and advertising production and intake has been globalized as well. Take Thomson Reuters for example, since Canadian mass media giant Thomson Corporation merged with the British Reuters Group; it is just about the biggest global financial information company and the new company surpasses nearly all other rivals (BBC, 2007).

Lastly, transnational media are dominated by global and regional development centres, and the info, productions and representations created because of it are moving through digital communication systems. In the meantime, the counter-flow can be found restrictedly, the ruling media assimilates the material and habits of advertising from other countries selectively. Such as for example film Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon, a story from China, but it is manufactured by Hollywood. In the same way, the story of animation film Mulan which created by Disney is dependant on Chinese history. But the culture and resources are taken from Chinese, the manifestation is global, and the maker remains a company of the United States.

The substance of 'cultural imperialism'

Before discussing on the essence of social imperialism thesis, I try to explore some key elements primarily.

Media: McQuail (1994) remarks that the press is a home window for folks to see the outside world, a guide to help the public understand mass activities, a system or a pick up truck to transfer information. However, McLuhan (1964) didn't buy into the proven fact that the media is only seen as a tool for carrying materials or information, in his view, 'the medium is the communication'. Every emergence of new mass media, whatever the specific articles spread, the multimedia form itself brings some information to individual society and it may make some kinds of social changes. McLuhan (1964, p. 7) further explains that the 'personal and cultural effects of any medium-that is, of any extension of ourselves-result from the new range that is created into our affairs by each extension of ourselves, or by any new technology'. Desire to he increases the proposition 'the medium is the note' is to remind individuals who the impacts induced by any media are more amazing than their specific contents. Quite simply, what multimedia can transmit is far more than the precise content; he tries to attract people's attention off from the content to the mass media itself. McLuhan (1964) also shows that 'mass media are the expansion of man', users of media are also the contents of media because they're creating contents, specifically the users of the web. In his view, Internet surfers change from other press consumers; regardless of what they do on the Internet they always create material. Folks are owners who are able to actively manage advertising and give requests. In the social imperialism thesis, the marketing establish associations between developed countries and developing countries, it could be separated into two categories, an example may be the productions of print out media, television, radio and film; the other is consumer goods such as Coca Cola, McDonald. Through these techniques, European countries can spread the information which they want to convey throughout the world.

Media culture: Since the media play an extremely important role in people's daily lives, modern population is integrally getting into the media modern culture, media and social communication has become a normal and major scenery for public. In the concept of cultural imperialism, multimedia culture is a culture of consumerism; the centre of it is capitalist values. Sklair (2012) proposes that there is a definite website link between consumerism and global capitalist system which handled by the capitalist multinational organization in the 20th century. The special quest for global capitalist system in the third world is to promote consumerism and also to allow consumers indirectly considering their use ability with looking over their own fruitful capacity. For instance, developing countries import commercial tv set and programs from developed countries, transmitting european Television set series, horror videos, detective experiences and cowboy films, making people face a world which may have passed for a long time or didn't are present in their real lives. Such marketing productions have a negative influence after people in expanding countries, eroding the national identities, restraining people's imagination and nature of participation.

Imperialist countries: American developed countries, especially america. Nonetheless there are simply just few amounts of these countries. After years of capitalist functions, they possess the majority of the world's resources and gather enormous wealth which results in the unbalanced development of the planet. Schiller (1991) confirms that they own not only 'hard ability' in political, economic and military domains but also cultural 'soft vitality' which is preponderant as well.

Developing countries: most of these countries had been unbiased after World War II; they dropped behind the western developed countries in political, economic, armed service and cultural areas. It could be said that they are still depending predicated on the economy of developed countries. In conditions of developed countries, the growing countries are huge consumer market segments that they can instil Western culture and worth and get advantages from.

Control: European countries closely impact expanding countries by using cultural imperialism; it is best characterized by settling dissimilarities with other countries and conserving from violation or infraction. Essentially, the main of ethnical imperialism is American countries, the circulation of global multimedia productions shows an apparent imbalance-they circulate in one-way move from european countries to the rest of the world (Varis, 1974). Due to the fact that American countries control multimedia systems and products, social imperialism enables under-developed countries make their economic, social, and politics policies and public values a lot like western specifications.

As a result, it appears that the five components of the cultural imperialism thesis can be integrated in a framework chart:

Transmitter Imperialist countries

 

Communicating content Multimedia culture (culture of consumerism)

 

Channels of communication media

 

Audiences Expanding countries

 

Communicating effect Cultural globalization

Schiller (1976) strains that ethnic imperialism is no isolated phenomenon; it is an integral part of the present day imperialism process. It includes several sensible characteristics in three aspects. First of all, the powerful countries in the financial domain, based on their powerful economic and capital power, expand their monetary, political and cultural influences to the rest of the world through the marketplace. It ends in a dominated and centered relationship between the developed capitalist countries (especially the United States and Western European countries) and the developing countries (the Third World countries, such as countries in SOUTH USA, Asia, and Africa). The products and fashion varieties of developed countries propagate abroad through the market, it could lead to specific patterns of demand and intake, so that ethnical values, behaviour and behaviours of developed countries can be consolidated and reinforced.

Furthermore, ethnic imperialism is an expansion of ethnic values, in other words dominating global culture through products or commodities which contain cultural values. In recent years, the Western countrywide export ethnical products to expanding countries and make them accept their principles, this triggers the invasions in ethnical success and development areas in growing countries. For example, although China is one of the net exporters of films besides the United States (Morley, 2006), in the film market of Chinese language mainland, the home films are greatly impacted by Hollywood films. Whenever Hollywood blockbusters like Transformers: Dark of the Moon is exhibiting at major cinemas, the package office buildings of the Chinese domestic films in the same period are always poor. Since Chinese language has recognized the cultural gentle power means a country's overall image, one of the departments of specialist called State Supervision of Radio, Film and Tv take several measures to support home videos, such as 'the month of home-made movies protection'. Which means every year, in a comparatively resolved time, there is merely few import films, the vast majority of the movies shown in cinema are domestic. Although this is performed to safeguard the domestic videos, this approach still causes controversy. While confronting these effects, producing countries not only face the risk of industrial colonization form, but also face too little creative imagination of the ethnic industry.

Finally, ethnic imperialism achieves ethnic growth through the dissemination of info products. In contemporary contemporary society, the strong civilizations of american countries come to pervade people's daily lives by means of mass media and popular ethnic products such as radio, tv, advertising, pop music, popular culture. Take america culture for example; it permeates almost every aspect of our day to day lives. A new Hollywood blockbuster could always start a watching boom around us; The pop music of American superstars such as Female Gaga and Rihanna is playing among most Chinese pubs and stores; an increasing quantity of teenagers become fans of the united states TV series; and the NBA show can be an eternal topic for basketball aficionados.

Main critiques of the ethnical imperialism

With the constant development of the globalization process and climb of audience studies, as the individual who first proposes the ethnic imperialism thesis, Schiller fits enormous troubles from other scholars. Especially after the end of the Chilly War, the ethnic imperialism thesis has brought on more controversies.

To get started with, there are increasing numbers of theorists realizing that the international communication process is a intricate composition, the one-way movement explains of ethnical imperialism oversimplifies this complex process of information flow. Regarding to Cunningham (1996), advertising globalization is no more a one-way circulation of media and ethnical products from the western countries to the rest of the world. In recent years, India has become to a major out-sourcing exporter, movies made by Bollywood have aroused considerable concerns. For example, as one of the most popular movies, 3 idiots has evoked worldwide repercussions. BBC (2010) reports that 'it has cracked records for Indian motion pictures in america, Australia, South Africa, Pakistan, Fiji and Kenya'. Within the American well-known film website IMDB, this film wins a score as high as 8. 2 things; in Rotten tomato vegetables, there are 92% of the people convinced that it will probably be worth watching. In addition, the climb of Korean popular culture has aroused the wide-spread interest not only in the Parts of asia, but also in the Western countries. In the lecture of the School of Leicester, the professor takes Young ladies' Era which created by S. M. Entertainment for example to illustrate popular culture. These samples demonstrated that global press and cultural propagation is a multi-directional stream process.

Secondly, the communication process is a complicated structure, there is no certain uniformity between encoding and decoding, and the similar information can be decoded by the different audiences in several ways. Which means audiences in the 3rd World may selectively accept information and principles which created by western media companies. Tomlinson (1997) criticizes that using mass media imperialism expresses the ethnic imperialism thesis is not proven. He is convinced that the multimedia is natural; and it is merely an intermediary of the communication process, it is neither a kind of ideology nor the central of modern culture. He also notes that audiences should not be regarded as unaggressive receptacles of press productions; they can not be dominated by multimedia. Schiller (1991) concurs and further explains that there are an integral part of active viewers, they understand the information in their own ways, by their own wisdom, most importantly, their understanding considered to have significance in ethnic hegemony resisting. Most importantly, it appears that each audience has a new knowledge of the same mass media products, and their attitudes derive from their own cultural background and experience. They admit information that they identify with and in the in the mean time, excluding those they dislike and disagree with. Somewhat, the decoding activities of effective, critical and resilient audiences weaken the result of ethnic imperialism gradually.

Lastly, the ethnical imperialism thesis appears to overlook the continuing significance of countrywide advertising systems and protectionism. Mainly because that films of the US occupy 80 % of the Western film market, While Western european movies only gets 2 % of the American market (Morley, 2006). To be able to protect domestic videos and television programs from the impact of the U. S. like products, some Europe (Canada and France) declare to restrict North american imported advertising products (Tomlinson, 1997). With mention to the center East countries, as a representative of the Saudi Arabian countrywide mass media system, Orbit feels that a BBC program about criticizing the Saudi Arabian human being rights has violated regulations and culture of Muslims, then it forbidden the transfer and use of satellite tv food in 1994 (Sakr, 2001). To sum up, in the contemporary global environment, since an increasing volume of countries realize to defend their social security, the force-feed type of the Western press productions spreading is becoming useless. The nationwide multimedia systems and protectionism play an increasingly important role in resisting the instillation of western cultures and worth.

Conclusion

As a central issue of the political and academic debate in the present era, different scholars have diverse views and opinions about globalization. Held (1999) provides an overview of various perspectives on globalization, he says that all the views can be split into three classes: Hyperglobalizers, Scepyics and Transformationalists. Differing from other two perspectives, transformationalists spotlight that firstly there is no single reason leading to globalization; additionally, as Giddens (1990 cited in Sreberny-Mohammadi, 2000) state governments that the outcome of the globalization process is uncertain. I agree with this point of view and in my view globalization is a complicated process, it can't be easily defined as positive or negative, it must be comprehended in more technical ways.

Above all, I claim that globalization is a process which is wide open and full of conflicts, its substance is to determine something for culture of exchanging and communicating, consequently, it could create a fresh media pattern. Media globalization can be an objective fact which brought on by the introduction of economical globalization, and the introduction of it can be an objective historical procedure for advertising development. The ethnic imperialism thesis is a negative way to understand multimedia globalization, and it oversimplifies this sophisticated process of information circulation. In this technique, exchange, collision and convergence between different civilizations are overall predicated on maintaining their own self-reliance, this can be a two-way process instead of a one-way course making majority of countries become similar to the Western style. Along the way of marketing globalization, communication and integration of varied cultures won't lead to cultural assimilation; on the other hand, diversification which emphasizes the dissimilarities and diversity is the expected style of individuals culture. Multicultural, not only identifies the cultural variety, but does mean the variations in deep-seated level of culture and these differences can be regarded on a global scale. It is a kind of social imperforation when it only assimilates or manages civilizations of other nations but does not acknowledge and absorb spectacular achievements from other nationwide cultures. The real marketing exchange is recognizing and absorbing the excellent and advanced ethnic elements, it is not only from basic composition but also the natural quality and nature.

  • More than 7,000 students prefer us to work on their projects
  • 90% of customers trust us with more than 5 assignments
Special
price
£5
/page
submit a project

Latest posts

Read more informative topics on our blog
Shiseido Company Limited Is A Japanese Makeup Company Marketing Essay
Marketing Strength: Among the main talents of Shiseido is its high quality products. To be able to satisfy customers, the company invested a great deal...
Fail To Plan You Plan To Fail Management Essay
Management This report will concentrate on two aspects of project management, their importance within the overall project management process. The report...
Waste To Prosperity Program Environmental Sciences Essay
Environmental Sciences Urban and rural regions of India produce very much garbage daily and hurting by various kinds of pollutions which are increasing...
Water POLLUTING OF THE ENVIRONMENT | Analysis
Environmental Studies Pollution Introduction Many people across the world can remember having walked on the street and seen smoke cigars in the air or...
Soft System Methodology
Information Technology Andrzej Werner Soft System Methodology can be described as a 7-step process aimed to help provide a solution to true to life...
Strategic and Coherent methods to Recruiting management
Business Traditionally HRM has been regarded as the tactical and coherent method of the management of the organizations most appreciated assets - the...
Enterprise Rent AN AUTOMOBILE Case Analysis Business Essay
Commerce With a massive network of over 6,000 local rental locations and 850,000 automobiles, Organization Rent-A-Car is the greatest rental car company...
The Work OF ANY Hotels Front Office Staff Travel and leisure Essay
Tourism When in a hotel there are careers for everyone levels where in fact the front office manager job and responsibilities,assistant professionals...
Strategy and international procedures on the Hershey Company
Marketing The Hershey Company was incorporated on October 24, 1927 as an heir to an industry founded in 1894 by Milton S. Hershey fiscal interest. The...
Check the price
for your project
we accept
Money back
guarantee
100% quality